Last year, for a change, I did "Atemporal Faves". The idea being to reflect the way that I'm more like a regular listener these days, a civilian, drifting across the archival space of streaming services, YouTube, and my own collection. As a result, what brings me delight in any given year will include some new records, as well as relatively recent releases (things from the year before, or the year before that, that I'd only just gotten around to hearing). Then there'd be new-to-me old stuff: reissues, but also just things from long ago I'd never heard before. And the final category: old favorites rediscovered, things heard once or twice long ago but returned to for a deeper listen with a different head.
A true reflection of a year's listening would be weighted to the not-now. Hence, Atemporal Faves.
Well, as it happens, I did hear more new releases in 2023 that I liked than has been the case for a while, most vaguely situated in "experimental pop" / electronic music on the edge of the dancefloor / electronic music with a song or vocal element. Some are mentioned below; others are not, even though they impressed me on a first listen. The problem I find is that there's so many things jostling for attention - newer new things, plus the endless variety of archival attractions - that often I never make it back for that second listen. Maybe the solution would be to have a system, a list, that ensures you make that return visit. But that would put everything into the category of work; listening would be trammeled with a sense of duty - something I'm inclined to avoid as much as possible.
In the jumble below, I've tried to stick with what stuck - songs and albums where it wasn't a question of conscientiously returning for another go, where I was irresistibly pulled back.
Various - Cease & Resist - Sonic Subversion & Anarcho Punk In The UK 1979-86
The song I played most in 2023 was "Girl On the Run" by Honey Bane - a very old song that I'm not 100% I ever heard before. I think I would have remembered - it's almost impossibly exciting. The bass playing alone!
The backing band on "Girl on The Run" is Crass - sounding better, musically, than on their own stuff. But Crass sounded just great on the song that I played second-most in 2023: "Bloody Revolutions". That's a very old song that I know very very well - my brother had a copy, played it incessantly - but I hadn't heard in it decades.
Both tunes appeared on this splendid compilation of anarcho-punk Cease & Resist - I blogged about it here, although the post quickly becomes a run-through of Honey Bane's career. As for "Bloody Revolutions", that got blogged about here, although the post largely focuses on the searing stridency of Eve Libertine's vocal.
June Tabor – "While Gamekeepers Lie Sleeping", "Heather Down the Moor", "The Scarecrow"
Thinking about it some more, the single song I played most in 2023 might actually have been "While Gamekeepers Lie Sleeping" - played in two forms: sung live in a TV studio, and also on record. Right close behind "Gamekeepers" would be "Heather Down the Moor". "The Scarecrow" - haunting and harrowed, as opposed to frolicsome and gamboling, as with the poacher and nookie-in-the-bracken songs - also got loads of spins. "Gamekeepers" and "Heather," though, are the ones I would so love to be able to sing. If I could, I'd sing them exactly as June does, every last skip and ripple. Paean here.
Lil Yachty, "The Ride", Let’s Start Here
"The Ride" is the most ecstatic piece of new music I heard all year. I know almost nothing about Lil Yachty, about his journey up to this point. Nor have I bothered to find out much about Let's Start Here, apart from picking up that it was a big career swerve and that it involves someone from Chairlift. Who I remember quite liking back in the whenever-it-was - early 2010s? - but feel reasonably confident in the belief that nothing in their past suggested they'd ever be capable of producing something as abandoned and let-loose as "The Ride". Let's Start Here has loads of other great moments ("pRETTy") but it's this song that really sends me.
Big Thief - "Simulation Swarm," "Little Things," "Blurred View"
Indie gets ever harder to define. You can sort of smell it, as a sensibility - but the sonic parameters are wide and getting wider. It doesn't necessarily involve guitars anymore, at least as the dominant musical texture. Much of what's called "indie" nowadays sounds more like singer-songwriter music. "Indie" perhaps is less a genre than a demographic, one that reconstitutes itself year after year, and that has abiding needs. Writerly lyrics are prized, sensitivity is the supreme value. It's music for the gentle people, which sometimes is the same as the genteel people. Idealistic, and consequently disillusioned - but it doesn't rail directly against the state of things hardly ever (that would be too aesthetically clumsy). Unlike R&B and Top 40 pop, it's rarely explicitly sexual (if it goes there, it's done poetically, tastefully). It's not built for a dancefloor - although people who love it will dance to it. A lot of the time it's about sadness, feeling hurt by life. But it can also brim over with bliss, try to capture fleeting moments of magic, when life becomes dream-like.
That's all good then. But of course indie has often been the lamest, take-this-to-the-knackers-yard-already sound around - and it's been like that for the past 30 years! Now and then, though, you'll hear something so surprisingly musical - so musically surprising - that questions of relevance become irrelevant. From the year before last year, listened to incessantly through 2023, "Simulation Swarm" and "Little Things" slipped past my barricades. For that I must thank my youngest son Eli, for playing within my earshot music I might otherwise never have heard, out of sheer prejudice.
Feeble Little Horse - "Picture", Girl With Fish, Hayday
After reading the two big end-of-year articles about the shoegaze resurgence I did something foolish and piled every 2023 / 2022 release mentioned into a gigantic playlist and then played it all the way through. Which took a couple of days. Probably not the fairest way to give these groups a chance. Any distinguishing qualities they conceivably possess got a little smushed.
Out of all that saturated redundancy, just a few caught my ear as really having any reason to exist: Zoon, I liked a lot, and some bits by Hotline TNT. Jane Remover and Yves Tumor had their moments.
But the group I liked the most was the one I already knew through Eli playing a tune or two: Feeble Little Horse. The first time that name flashed up on the car stereo I laughed out loud - such a ridiculously echt-indie name for a group, yet also so right for this fragile, jelly-legged sound. I really like the droopy vocals, the curling girly melodies, the drifting off-tune guitar-tones, the shapely shapelessness of the songs. You have heard it all before, except you haven't, quite, heard it exactly like this.
Alongside "Simulation Swarm", "Picture" might be the most sheerly beautiful, subtly inventive song I've heard in a couple of years.
patten, Mirage FM
I mentioned that there were a lot of art-pop / experimental pop / edge-of-dance things that impressed me on a first listen but I never went back to. Mirage FM was one of the much smaller number that drew me back. It's a crinkly, spangly sort of sound poised pleasantly on a cusp between eeriness and ecstasy. Some tunes, like "Forever" and "Alright" reminded me of a less groove-functional, unsteady-as-she-goes Todd Edwards. A commenter at the Retromania blog said Burial - same difference, really! This album is an extension of the vocal science / sample-choir aesthetic, but employing the latest technology, generative AI.
Listening just now, again, I suddenly wondered whether I would have guessed that, if I hadn't read about the text-to-sound technique involved before I ever listened. Maybe I would have just taken it to be an extreme use of Melodyne or some other vocal design tool pushed to the absolute limit? I am not sure with AI-created music that I am able yet to hear the sort of oh-yes-that’s-what-they-are-using aspect that you get when you heard something that was e.g. pushing Autotune to its limits. (Something similar happened with the last Holly Herndon album, where my favorite track turned out not to involve machine-learning or Spawn at all but older forms of vocal processing).
Perhaps it's a case where actually knowing more would enhance the experience, not diminish it. So with Mirage FM, rather than simply presenting the outcome of the process for our disoriented delectation, it might have been more intriguing to know the precise instructions given to Stable Diffusion that resulted in the raw material of each track's make-up, and trying to identify the correlations.
(This flashes me back to my thoughts about sampling in Energy Flash - that if you used the sampler in such an extreme, abstractified way that the sample source was unrecognisable, you might as well be using synthesis.... that what was idiomorphic about the sampler was the distortion or stretching of the known as opposed to the obliteration and obscuring of it .... "known" not necessarily meaning that you recognise it as a quote or citation, but that you recognise it as belonging to a genre or originating in an instrument. The analogy here would be the hall of mirrors, where what makes it unsettling is the grotesque deformation of the human face and form... if it was just a formless blur of flickering color, that wouldn't be perturbing)
Lee Gamble, Models
Another arty electronic release that involves neural networks and abstractified vocals. And that got repeat listens from me.
Gamble appears to have reverted to the gaseous abstraction of his pre-polemical work - at least, I didn't glean a sense that there was a political point being made here, even obliquely. If so, all to the good, I think. Four years since the infamous article, I have moved further still from thinking there's much point to politicking-through-music. Preaching to the converted, critiquing for the predisposed - these are just points on a spectrum.
Here, I seem to be part of something called The Aesthetic Turn. But really I have been there for a while. (It's also a return to how I felt about music in post-postpunk times). My gut feeling is that whatever it is music does for us, it's not really about education, enlightenment, "moral rearmament". But nor is music a particularly good vehicle for making us better informed. There are after all a superabundance of avenues and mechanisms out there to achieve that - whatever use being informed actually is, on its own.
But music - music has other things to offer.
(What about the other arts - film, literature, visual art? I recoil similarly from the overtly didactic and sententious, while acknowledging that there are books, movies, paintings, that have made me think - think differently. And I suppose music has done that, in tandem with the discourse around music - the writing, the arguing. Then again, I wonder whether I would have found a way to those sort of thoughts anyway. (Hence "critiquing for the predisposed").
(But what about "Bloody Revolutions"? Surely that's a case of music-as-politicking-as-excitement-as-potentially-lifechanging.... I guess, but I think the lyric content of the song - which I don't necessarily agree with anyway, anymore than I agree with Crass's "if voting changed anything they'd ban it" / "doesn't matter who you vote for, the government wins" worldview - the lyric content is a means to the excitement. It's their belief that fuels the engine, their fiery fervour that ignites the spark. The disconcerting thought here is that the conjunction of politics and pop has done far more for pop than it has ever done for politics. Listening to "Anarchy in the UK" and "God Save the Queen", even now - it feels like the world is shaking to bits. But step outside the space of the recording, and, nearly fifty years on, King Charles III sits on the throne and it's a horde of anarcho-fascists who "wanna destroy" and are doing a pretty good job of it right now.
Tom Caruana – Inner Space – Instrumentals
An "idiomorphic" use of sampling, one of many types, here - a tribute through distillation / intensification. The source honored: Can. There's actually a non-instrumentals version of this with loads of rapping on top; it works, and is actually the primary version of the project. But I prefer the mental instros. Blogged here.
King Krule – Space Heavy
Saw him by chance (I was there to interview Dry Cleaning) at Primavera late in 2022 and found it, at top volume, borderline unpleasant, yet also oddly gripping. This album, more subdued and whatever the opposite of in-your-face is, has some wonderful moments. "Seaforth" and "If Only It Was Warmth" remind me a bit of A.R. Kane - the woozy, mumbled vocals, the barely-there feeling.
Alwin Nikolais - Choreosonic Music of the New Dance Theater of Alwin Nikolais +++
Best of this year's bounteous crop of Creel Pones. The first disc of this whopper falls into that small category that makes me so happy: Creels I discovered all by myself, well before the label reissued them. Choreosonic Music of the New Dance Theater I found in a yard sale at the East Village apartment block over the road from us. Just $1! Here's something substantive I wrote about Nikolais from a few years ago.
Various - Música Electrónica Latinoamericana
Richard Dawson, "Jogging"
My students often introduce me to things I have never heard of. That's not surprising, given how much music there is out there, and how young people get into things laterally (you would be shocked by the extent to which they don't read music journalism, like, at all), through word of mouth and the kind of social media they favor and algo-driven nudges. However I was really surprised when one of my very-American students brought this Dawson tune in for a class we did on innovation in lyric writing: something so utterly British in its reference points and overall flavor. I guess the malaise the song anatomises is a transnational affect, even if the particulars are extremely UK-specific. In that respect, it's as harrowingly funny as Dry Cleaning.
Jabu - Boiling Wells / Various - Always and Forever (Do You Have Peace)
Trip hop seems to be having a moment... These artists aren't exactly making trip hop, but they are very Bristol - either actually from the city or from a Bristol-of-the-mind. There's that distinctive blend of sensuality, sparsity and sadness. "Dubby" - not in terms of specific techniques applied, but in a quality of subtraction, a not-all-there feeling. Echoes of A.R. Kane in moments here too.
Vanishing Twin, Afternoon X
Sometimes I think Vanishing Twin are just the Scarfolk of music - meticulously executed derivativeness. But they derivatate so consummately, mining this sweet seam between Broadcast, Belbury Poly, Stereolab, that I can't help being seduced.
Patrick McNee and Honor Blackman, "Kinky Boots"
What would you call this genre of dinky-yet-demented, fusspot-arrangement style of comedy-pop? I can't work out what it is sourced in.
Much the same applies to this quite-different-sounding near-contemporaneous boot-themed tune.
Mozart Estate Pop-Up! Ker-Ching! And The Possibilities Of Modern Shopping
Some of Lawrence's funniest lines and catchiest tunes since that first Denim album.
Moon Wiring Club, Sepia Cat City
Another year, another excellent Ian Hodgson album
A.R. Kane – A.R.Kive
Q-and-A'd about here.
Dorothy Carter - Waillee Waillee
The Criminal Minds – The Masterworks Remastered Volume 1 to 6 (Kniteforce)
Earth Leakage Trip - "No Idea", "The Ice Cream Van From Hell"
Harmonia - "Walky Talky"
I worship Neu! and I worship Cluster (up to and including Zuckerzeit) but for some reason I've never fully clicked with Harmonia. It washes past me a bit. But then suddenly this year the golden rolling grandeur of "Walky Talky" ran me right over.
Headhunters – "God Made Me Funky"
One of the things about recorded music I love is when you can "see it" - diagrammatically, as blocs of sound distributed across space - but it also has this totally somatic and haptic impact. This perfectly produced funk track works simultaneously as a mechanism whose moving parts you can gaze at in an almost distanced way and a seething fever reaching into your body, coiling its tightness inside your insides.
these also served
Andre 3000, New Blue Sun
Force of One Crew - Weekend Rush June 1993
Cocteau Twins, uuuurv complète (ou plutôt, presque complète)
Prince Far I & The Arabs, "The Right Way"
Jack DeJohnette, "The Right Time"
James Blake Playing Robots In Heaven
Tek lintowe, "Ween wao"
Joel Gressel, "Points In Time, "Crossing", "P-Vibes"
Public Image Ltd, "Hawaii", End Of World
Position Normal Modern And Unique
Matmos, Return To Archive
Catherine Christer Hennix, Solo for Tamburium
Lisel, Patterns for Auto-Tuned Voices
Lloyd Cole, On Pain
Piotr Kurek, Smartwoods
Playboi Carti – "No Time"
D'Athiz, Summer Banger / Abashwe
Beatriz Ferreyra – UFO Forest +
Tirzah, trip9love...???
John Medeski, music in The Curse
Hidden Horse, Incorporeal
Stereolab + Nurse With Wound, Simple Headphone Mind / Trippin With the Birds
Various Artists, Gespensterland
Kilkenny Electroacoustic Research Laboratory Anthology Vol. 2
Various Artists, Synthetic Bird Music
Low Tec, Old Economy
Lo Five, Persistence of Love
Grouper – Way Their Crept
Oneohtrix Point Never, Again
Elizabeth Parker – Future Perfect
Various - The NID Tapes: Electronic Music from India 1969-1972
Bob Stanley & Pete Wiggs – Three Day Week (When The Lights Went Out 1972-1975)
Cherelle + Alexander O’Neal – "Saturday Love"
Stray Cats, "Runaway Boy"
Duster, Capsule Losing Contact
West Coast Pop Art Experimental Band, "I Won't Hurt You"
Boredoms – Vision Creation Newsun
